Restoration vs. Replacement: What’s Best After Property Damage?
When disaster strikes — whether from water, fire, or mold — one of the first questions you’re faced with is: Should I restore or replace? At BlueHaven Water Damage & Restoration, we help Boise property owners make smart decisions that balance cost, safety, and long-term value.
What’s the Difference Between Restoration and Replacement?
- Restoration: Cleaning, drying, sanitizing, and repairing what can be saved after damage
- Replacement: Removing and discarding damaged materials, then installing new ones
When Is Restoration the Better Choice?
In many cases, restoration is faster, cheaper, and more environmentally friendly. Restoration is typically recommended when:
- Water damage is recent and materials haven’t deteriorated
- Smoke damage is surface-level, not deep into structures
- Mold contamination is isolated and caught early
- Insurance prefers restoration over full replacement
✅ Restoration often applies to items like drywall, wood flooring, carpets, and cabinetry — depending on severity and contamination.
When Should You Replace Instead?
There are times when replacement is the safest or most cost-effective path:
- Black water (sewage) contamination
- Structural materials are warped, rotten, or mold-infested
- Smoke damage has penetrated porous materials like insulation
- The cost of repair exceeds 50% of replacement cost
How We Help You Decide
Our certified restoration team assesses each situation individually, factoring in:
- The source and severity of damage
- Material type and moisture exposure time
- Health risks and contamination
- Cost of repair vs replacement
- Insurance coverage and approval
Cost Comparison: Restore vs Replace
| Item | Average Restoration | Average Replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Carpet | $150–$400 (cleaning/drying) | $800–$2,000 (new install) |
| Drywall | $300–$600 (patch/paint) | $1,000+ (full tear-out) |
| Wood Floors | $500–$1,200 (refinish/dry) | $3,000–$6,000 (replace) |
We Work With Your Insurance
BlueHaven documents all damage with detailed reporting to help your insurance company determine what’s covered for repair vs. replacement. We’ll even communicate with your adjuster to speed up the process.
Need Help Deciding? Get a Free Damage Assessment
If you’re unsure whether to restore or replace, we’ll guide you through the best option based on your situation and goals. Call (208) 279-2505 or schedule a free on-site estimate today.